Penelope Bourbon has been making waves with its creative finishing techniques and approachable flavor profiles. Their Toasted Series is no exception—designed for those who crave a bolder sip while still appreciating balance and finesse. Built on the foundation of their four-grain straight bourbon, the Toasted Series goes through a second maturation in a custom-toasted barrel, layering complexity onto an already versatile spirit. Whether you’re a neat pour patriot or a toasted barrel trooper, this one deserves a debrief.
Penelope Toasted Bourbon
Mission Briefing
- Operation: Penelope Toasted Series Bourbon
- Command: Penelope Bourbon Co. – Roselle, NJ (distilled in Indiana, aged in KY)
- Classification: Straight Bourbon Finished in Toasted Barrel
- Rations: 74% Corn, 16% Wheat, 7% Rye, 3% Malted Barley
- Firepower: Varies by batch – typically 50% ABV / 100 Proof
- Time in Service: 4–5 years + toasted barrel finish
- Enlistment Fee: ~$65 (750ml)
Recon Notes (Nose)
Right off the tarmac, you’re hit with a sweet barrage—marshmallow fluff, toasted vanilla, and caramelized sugar. Dig a little deeper and you’ll catch a waft of fresh oak, cinnamon bark, and a soft char like the aftermath of a well-controlled campfire. Smells like a s’mores operation in full swing.
Frontline Flavor (Palate)
The initial sip lands with classic Penelope softness—thanks to that four-grain mash—before the toasted barrel starts throwing elbows. Expect rich vanilla custard, dark brown sugar, baking spice, and a warm hit of oak char. The wheat rounds things out with a smooth body, but the rye sneaks in a little pepper near the end like a late-arriving wingman. This is a bourbon I’d jot down in my tasting journal for its layered flavor and toasted finish.”
After Action (Finish)
Medium-to-long finish with lingering notes of toasted coconut, cocoa, and gentle spice. The fade is like a tactical retreat—slow, controlled, and leaving a lasting impression. No burn, just a warm salute.
Debrief
Penelope Toasted Bourbon is a bottle that brings both flavor and finesse to the fight. It’s layered enough to impress neat drinkers and bold enough to elevate your Old Fashioned. At around $65, it’s not a budget pour, but it earns its stripes with rich complexity and a distinctive profile that’ll appeal to toasted barrel fanatics. Whether you’re boots-on-ground new or a seasoned whiskey vet, this one’s worth adding to the rotation.
🎖 Whiskey Orders (Rating)
Active Duty Pour – Reliable and enjoyable daily drinker.
